combat_doomerism [he/him]

not sure how you found me, I only lurk now. dm if you want to tell me something for whatever reason.

  • 3 Posts
  • 130 Comments
Joined 9 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 1st, 2024

help-circle











  • Like, maybe it’s reflective of an attitude that affected things later on, but it’s a bit of a stretch to think, like, that was the thing that set them on the path of defeat.

    i’m not sure either, again not a harsh criticism of the ussr, i just think the only chance for the soviet union to win the cold war was for the west to collapse first, too many good communists died in ww2 that it was always going to fall during the cold war, so in retrospect things that ended up strengthening the west and harming the (already miniscule, especially in the US) chance of revolution





  • i think you should be bolder with your opinions. ultimately i think she is doing that really annoying thing all ultras do, where they armchair quarterback from the comfort of their homes with perfect leftist ideas that never have to actually be sullied by the harsh truths of reality. i actually dont even 100% disagree, trusting america to actually help, especially once it’s clear you’re already winning, was a mistake. however, im also not harshly criticizing them for it, i think with 10s of millions of lives in your hands it makes sense you would do whatever you can to delay war (attempts to appease the liberals in the 30s) and try to end the war as quickly as possible (appeasing the liberals in the 40s). i have the benefit of hindsight, that the path the soviet union took led to them losing the cold war, and maybe advising communists to be more militant during the 30s and 40s would have changed the outcome of the cold war.

    regardless, more to my original point, we need to stop dismissing these things as “events from 100 years ago”. these are very important things for us to study, and how we view them and which lessons we take from that study are immensely important as it will inform the actions we take today and in the future in our struggle against barbarism. this is not to say there arent pointless things from 100 years ago that we need to brush past, but i see the kind of sentiment im arguing against way too much on this site. you need to firm in your opinions like this, and not let things go. not to say you should hold this against her and be petty, but i also dont think you should go out of your way to avoid ideological arguments. if you find yourself getting upset to the point where you’re struggling not to resort to insults, i think it’s fine to ask to step away from something and come back to it later