• 0 Posts
  • 1.73K Comments
Joined 3 年前
cake
Cake day: 2023年7月1日

help-circle

  • Hm, they could. I don’t think that objectification is truly always a bad thing. It obviously sucks when people use you, but being ‘the friend with …’ can also be an excuse to see people more often. Kind of like how the social function of a lot of holidays is just to bring distant people together again.

    Sexual objectification is of particular importance because it has ties to the cultural perception of women, rape culture, etc., but it’s also fine to just think your wife who you admire for her strong perserverance and creativity also has titties that are fire.


  • I talk about survivability because it’s easy to grasp, but I’m really referring to any kind of incentive structure. Success, for instance, while similar to survival, is not actually the same thing. Prestige can be something that motivates somebody to be a great artist.

    The kinds of lazy basement dwellers I’m talking about are more like people with social anxiety refusing to take phone calls in place of texts. Or, people with executive disfunction watching YouTube instead of getting any work done, which I can speak to personally because I hated doing homework and would watch YouTube instead until the anxiety of deadline failure pushed me into finally getting something done. But that homework was useful.

    I obviously believe in the human ability to rise above yesterday’s achievements. I am an example of such. I used to have the social anxiety that would have prevented me from talking to you now. I overcame that by having a very insisting personality.

    But even so, there are people today who could, even through the tiresome hustle of working day to day, learn to play piano and want to but never do. My concern is leaving people like this to their own devices. To a person who willingly shucks all of life’s goals, I think that giving them goals is actually better for them.

    There is one particular way in which I think a Star Trek utopia might be overly optimistic, putting it in the realm of hopeful fantasy, and it’s that it overlooks the very biological urge to hibernate. The principle of least action, at least as far as education goes, would be not to.



  • Using AI to pass these arbitrary requirements needed to exist in an arbitrary society

    I understand what you’re saying, but I think this still represents a very cynical view of education.

    Think about it this way: in times past, if we wanted to eat an elk, we had to chase it down and catch it. We had to learn to be good hunters as a prerequisite to living comfortable lives.

    Today, we have scant few hunters. We might call this a good thing. We no longer need to be hunters to be comfortable, our quality of life has improved vastly. I would naturally agree with this.

    However, another consequence is that we can now live very sedentary lives. Food is no longer an incentive to exercise, which means that, as a society, our physical health may actually be worse. And not only that, physical exercise is connected to mental health, too. A lack of exercise can mean that people are more anxious, more frustrated, more cranky, etc.

    There are some people who still exercise today, aware that they need it, but for a lot of people, most of them even, the carrot leading them is gone and so they see no reason to bother. It’s irritating to bother, actually. I fear the same thing happening to education.

    The future Star Trek world that you’re looking for requires that people be self-interested in their own development, and motivated enough to follow through on it. And a lot of people would be. But I don’t know if a society would be.

    Missing the carrot, a lot of people might be content to just remain stupid their entire lives.

    So what I’m saying is, getting a degree for a job may or may not be arbitrary, but getting an education, even a forced one, for your society is not. Not as much, anyway.

    I’ll put forward one other thing. Racists have a harder time devloping in mixed communities. Living around the would-be subjects of ire, seeing what they’re actually like, makes it harder for their stupid, racist mythology to take hold. But imagine that somebody said they wanted to live separately anyway, that they didn’t care about this arbitrary, interracial education, and that we as a society had to, for some reason, respect this about them.

    I obviously don’t care about imposing on racists an education that would make them less racist. I think it’s important, even.

    I also sympathize with the world as it is being unfair to students. But, I don’t respect the subversion of learning itself.