I have just logged in on my own Lemmy instance, and I see a list of banned users in the administrative area, from other instances. I have not banned anyone myself.

How does it work? If you’re banned from an instance, you’re banned from the whole federation?

  • MadMaurice
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    When you say “my own instance” do you mean an instance you set up yourself and are the administrator? If so how and where did you set it up?

      • MadMaurice
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        There should be a public modlog which should tell you when and why someone was banned. I haven’t set up my lemmy instance yet, did you maybe leave your instance unprotected for long enough so some could add bans? Or did you use an old database with data from a previous instance? Did you pull the wrong docker image?

          • MadMaurice
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            1 year ago

            What I don’t understand is why does server B have to tell server A that user@B is banned on B, instead of just not letting user@B login anymore and thus disallowing the creation of further content by user@B?

            And maybe A wants the content by user@B, so why can server B dictate bans that server A has to enforce?

            What happens if server A ignores them?

            As an instance would I be able to flood another instance’s ban list by just pretending to have trillions of users that are all banned?

            • italiota@lemmy.1204.orgOP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              1 year ago

              Given that I asked the question in the first place, here is how I make sense of it after some answers and looking at the modlog.

              What I don’t understand is why does server B have to tell server A that user@B is banned on B, instead of just not letting user@B login anymore and thus disallowing the creation of further content by user@B?

              Because A sees B’s content, but on A server. user@B is banned on B, hence, A keeps seeing B content, but not user@B content on B. user@B can still register on A and post there.

              And maybe A wants the content by user@B, so why can server B dictate bans that server A has to enforce?

              Because user@B’s content, while copied and displayed on A, is still B’s content. B bans the user and their content everywhere. Again, user@B can register elsewhere and start posting.

              What happens if server A ignores them?

              From what I can see, if I am A, I cannot unban user@B in any way. user@B can register in my instance, though. I can ban user@A afterwards (or not).

              As an instance would I be able to flood another instance’s ban list by just pretending to have trillions of users that are all banned?

              I think so. I federate with Beehaw. If Beehaw bans everyone, my banned user list will get quite long.