• GreenSkree@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    9 months ago

    Stopping the war industry and ceasing all sort of imperialistic activities, even on one side alone will put at end on most conflicts but every ruler is in for more wealth and power, they don’t want to stop. This does not mean that because someone is doing it everyone has to follow suit, it literally means that every corrupted politician and their government seek war.

    I think this is overly naive and simplistic.

    So do you agree that palestine should have the rights to defend themself against israel?

    (I’m not as well versed in this conflict, but a few thoughts from my perspective)

    The situation and power dynamics are quite different there. I don’t have any easy answer unfortunately.

    • Palestine doesn’t have a conventional army or a means to fight Israel the same way Ukraine is fighting Russia.
    • Israel’s reaction and occupation of Gaza Strip is horrible.
    • Historically, Israel’s treatment of Palestinian people has been completely unacceptable.
    • Hamas’ actions have been awful, both historically and with the first attack in October where they started this conflict. Their attacks routinely target civilians, which is unacceptable.

    So, if there are people living in Palestine who want to fight the occupiers, that perspective makes sense to me. So, at the most basic level, yes – I think they should be able to defend themselves. However, Hamas historically seems prioritized only in hurting Israel, and their actions routinely hurt Palestine in a number of ways. Plus, supporting terrorist organizations (like Hamas) with arms/training/etc has worked out poorly for the US in the past.

    So, unfortunately, I think there are no “good guys” here (besides the civilians caught up in this who want peace). I think both Israel and Hamas steered into this conflict when alternative course of actions existed. Conflict between these groups has been ongoing for decades and has no good or simple solution.