I noticed responding to posts in communities hosted at lemmy.ml gives the following warning:

This post is hosted on lemmy.ml which will ban you for saying anything negative about China, Russia or Putin. Tread carefully.

While I see where this is coming from and I agree with the general sentiment, I’m not sure it’s a great idea to include such a message. I basically read it as an invitation to be off-topic and to derail conversations in order to annoy the admins. While it comes from a point of good intentions, it can be disheartening for the people running communities on Lemmy.ml to receive comments about Russia from users basically trying to get banned, in communities that has nothing to do with this issue.

It’s unfortunate, but a lot of valuable older communities are still hosted on lemmy.ml, and I think PieFed users should be encouraged to be constructive and on-topic users there as they should be everywhere else.

An alternative suggestion: Maybe it could be useful to remind people which community they are posting in? Like, “This community is dedicated to renewable energy. Please keep this in mind when contributing to the discussion”. Then again, that would be a mess to implement in a good way.

  • rufus
    3·
    8 months ago

    I’m not sure if it’s necessarily bad. There is precedent for unconventional moderation practices on lemmy.ml and I’d like to see some people to move away from the large communities there and their moderators. A feature like this could help with that.

    I’d like to follow a more scientific approach. Implement that feature and then see if it contributes to a healthier discussion or has negative side-effects. At this point it’s just speculation and we can’t tell if it helps or attracts trolls. Then decide what to do with that actual information.