This is kinda funny, but extremely fake. I’m a second generation immigrant. I can attest that obtaining a credit card without citizenship is basically impossible, and very difficult even with a green card.
Also, when people from Asia travel they usually have dual currency credit cards that work very well in their country and the west. All the major financial organizations have offices in China. Hell you can get a dual currency card from the bank of China in MasterCard or Visa.
It is if your country isn’t on the western credit based system… A recent immigrant isn’t going to have a loan or mortgage, and most often are in low income jobs, or even paid under the table.
But, I’m guessing that’s not what’s happening in your situation. If that were the case wouldn’t you have just claimed that you or your brother were immigrants?
And my point still stands… Just because your sister in-law or brother have green cards and have access to credit cards doesn’t mean that’s the norm for most immigrants. It also doesn’t mean that it wasn’t difficult for your sister in-law.
You literally don’t have a credit rating when you come here as an immigrant. So unless you have someone willing to co-sign and accept potential liability, then you’re not going to be able to borrow anything.
I’ve heard discovery has a specific card that a lot of middle/upper class. immigrants apply for, but even then it’s still hard to get a line of credit unless you have a fairly well established work history.
I think a lot of people on Lemmy aren’t really exposed to many immigrant communities. It seems like most of you think the majority of immigrants in the country come from middle or upper class families, most likely because your idea of an immigrant is someone who came here for school.
That may be more common nowadays due to the rising importance of sponsorships for green cards, but nearly half of the current immigrant population happened prior to the 2000s. When most immigrants were entering the country without any kind of support network in the states.
For these people, establishing a foothold in banking and credit institutions could take a decade of hard work.
how recent do u mean, like sure if u been here less than a year and u dont have a green card probably hard but when u have it its not hard at all, how do u think people exist in this country before the 5 years for citizenship are up or even beyond that if they never get citizenship. also the person in the post studied in the usa they probably lived here atleast 4 years.
how recent do u mean, like sure if u been here less than a year and u dont have a green card probably hard but when u have it its not hard at all
I think you are vastly underestimating how hard it is to get a start in a totally new country where you don’t speak the language.
how do u think people exist in this country before the 5 years for citizenship are up or even beyond that if they never get citizenship.
Cash… Most immigrants rely on cash and don’t really trust banking institutions. There are plenty of check cashing services that charge predatory amounts of money to cash checks for people who aren’t able to utilize or get a checking account.
also the person in the post studied in the usa they probably lived here atleast 4 years.
On a student visa… You can open a bank account with a student visa passport, and a letter explaining your residency status. If you apply for an individual tax ID number and get assigned a social security number, you can apply for a credit card. But you don’t really have any credit history, and they know you’re only in the country temporarily.
I went through all this when my cousin came from Korea to go to school, it was a lot easier for him to just use his dual currency card.
man i am an immigrant and most people im close with are too its not that hard to get a credit card, i have seen it tons of times people get here and as soon as they get their work permit and have a couple month of direct deposit they can get a shitty credit card and after that they get a decent one, also it doesnt really matter how much of a pain in the ass it would have been for the student if his plan was to do this its perfectly doable.
like i literally know so many people who have been here only a little over a year and are already drowning in credit card loans, when my family emigrated my mom got a credit card less than a year into living here. migrants get credit cards all the time its super normal are u sure we are even talking about the same country here.
like i literally know so many people who have been here only a little over a year and are already drowning in credit card loans, when my family emigrated my mom got a credit card less than a year into living here. migrants get credit cards all the time its super normal are u sure we are even talking about the same country here.
Lol, this makes no sense. First of all the credit cards they typically give have very low credit lines, often depending on the amount you deposit. So even if they got a card it wouldn’t be possible to rack up a lot of debt. Secondly, if you have no credit rating and you do rack up debt, your credit rating is going to be awful and you won’t be able to get better cards.
One of the only ways to build up your credit at this stage is to use your card responsibly and keep it paid off. That’s unless you have someone who can co-sign your applications, or become an authorized user on someone else’s account.
doesnt really matter how much of a pain in the ass it would have been for the student if his plan was to do this its perfectly doable.
Oh yeah, I’m going to go from having no established credit, to being able to rack up 140k in unsecured credit in 4 years, on a student visa. Bullshit.
First Gen immigrant here. Credit card obtainment is itself not that hard if you already have guardians or sponsors who are willing to cosign your paperworks. If you don’t even have that then it would have been impossible for you to even legally get into this sh*t hole to begin with so I have no idea why you said it was hard.
The hard part is getting a credit line as high as 100k without a stable income and high credit score. Even many US citizens I known don’t even have close to that numbers in all their accounts combined fresh out of college. The conman in the post either already have rich relatives who are paying it back or must have lost even more cash withdrawn from China to bankroll his “scam”
Lastly, regardless of how you spent that money, it’s still entrapped inside the US economy and thus not enrich his own country at all. Unless they bought gold or cash back to China, of course
This is kinda funny, but extremely fake. I’m a second generation immigrant. I can attest that obtaining a credit card without citizenship is basically impossible, and very difficult even with a green card.
Also, when people from Asia travel they usually have dual currency credit cards that work very well in their country and the west. All the major financial organizations have offices in China. Hell you can get a dual currency card from the bank of China in MasterCard or Visa.
Getting a credit card with a green card is not hard at all, what are u smoking.
It is if your country isn’t on the western credit based system… A recent immigrant isn’t going to have a loan or mortgage, and most often are in low income jobs, or even paid under the table.
Nah, my SIL is Chinese with a green card and has credit cards and even a mortgage. Arrived in 2017.
Sister in law… Which means she is married to an American. I didn’t say it was impossible, just very difficult for most immigrants.
You know it’s possible for two green card holders to be married, right?
But, I’m guessing that’s not what’s happening in your situation. If that were the case wouldn’t you have just claimed that you or your brother were immigrants?
And my point still stands… Just because your sister in-law or brother have green cards and have access to credit cards doesn’t mean that’s the norm for most immigrants. It also doesn’t mean that it wasn’t difficult for your sister in-law.
You literally don’t have a credit rating when you come here as an immigrant. So unless you have someone willing to co-sign and accept potential liability, then you’re not going to be able to borrow anything.
I’ve heard discovery has a specific card that a lot of middle/upper class. immigrants apply for, but even then it’s still hard to get a line of credit unless you have a fairly well established work history.
I think a lot of people on Lemmy aren’t really exposed to many immigrant communities. It seems like most of you think the majority of immigrants in the country come from middle or upper class families, most likely because your idea of an immigrant is someone who came here for school.
That may be more common nowadays due to the rising importance of sponsorships for green cards, but nearly half of the current immigrant population happened prior to the 2000s. When most immigrants were entering the country without any kind of support network in the states.
For these people, establishing a foothold in banking and credit institutions could take a decade of hard work.
how recent do u mean, like sure if u been here less than a year and u dont have a green card probably hard but when u have it its not hard at all, how do u think people exist in this country before the 5 years for citizenship are up or even beyond that if they never get citizenship. also the person in the post studied in the usa they probably lived here atleast 4 years.
I think you are vastly underestimating how hard it is to get a start in a totally new country where you don’t speak the language.
Cash… Most immigrants rely on cash and don’t really trust banking institutions. There are plenty of check cashing services that charge predatory amounts of money to cash checks for people who aren’t able to utilize or get a checking account.
On a student visa… You can open a bank account with a student visa passport, and a letter explaining your residency status. If you apply for an individual tax ID number and get assigned a social security number, you can apply for a credit card. But you don’t really have any credit history, and they know you’re only in the country temporarily.
I went through all this when my cousin came from Korea to go to school, it was a lot easier for him to just use his dual currency card.
man i am an immigrant and most people im close with are too its not that hard to get a credit card, i have seen it tons of times people get here and as soon as they get their work permit and have a couple month of direct deposit they can get a shitty credit card and after that they get a decent one, also it doesnt really matter how much of a pain in the ass it would have been for the student if his plan was to do this its perfectly doable.
like i literally know so many people who have been here only a little over a year and are already drowning in credit card loans, when my family emigrated my mom got a credit card less than a year into living here. migrants get credit cards all the time its super normal are u sure we are even talking about the same country here.
Lol, this makes no sense. First of all the credit cards they typically give have very low credit lines, often depending on the amount you deposit. So even if they got a card it wouldn’t be possible to rack up a lot of debt. Secondly, if you have no credit rating and you do rack up debt, your credit rating is going to be awful and you won’t be able to get better cards.
One of the only ways to build up your credit at this stage is to use your card responsibly and keep it paid off. That’s unless you have someone who can co-sign your applications, or become an authorized user on someone else’s account.
Oh yeah, I’m going to go from having no established credit, to being able to rack up 140k in unsecured credit in 4 years, on a student visa. Bullshit.
First Gen immigrant here. Credit card obtainment is itself not that hard if you already have guardians or sponsors who are willing to cosign your paperworks. If you don’t even have that then it would have been impossible for you to even legally get into this sh*t hole to begin with so I have no idea why you said it was hard.
The hard part is getting a credit line as high as 100k without a stable income and high credit score. Even many US citizens I known don’t even have close to that numbers in all their accounts combined fresh out of college. The conman in the post either already have rich relatives who are paying it back or must have lost even more cash withdrawn from China to bankroll his “scam”
Lastly, regardless of how you spent that money, it’s still entrapped inside the US economy and thus not enrich his own country at all. Unless they bought gold or cash back to China, of course
Pretty large “if” for a lot of immigrant communities.