• Sunforged@lemmy.worldOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    1 year ago

    Holdo being introduced as a leading heroic character then killed later…

    Holdo was a supporting character in Poe’s character arch meant to play against his off the cuff tendencies. The sacrifice was meant to be a jumping point for expected growth in the final act. That isn’t a plot thread cut.

    Luke being killed for no reason…

    It was both epic, had it’s reason and thanks to force ghosts was never meant to be the end of Luke’s plot.

    I’m not gonna defend the Canto Bight plot as I obviously have issues with it. I would argue though that it’s ultimately a plot thread that was pointless rather than one cut before its end.

    Snoke being set up as an immensely powerful bad guy, but later killed without any more explanation of who/what he was…

    Snoke was the emperor stand in from The Force Awakens, which had no original ideas of it’s own. Snoke needed to die in order to tell an original story. Ben Solo was an infinitely more interesting and complexe villain to focus on. Why would any fan be upset at Snoke’s death, the story was set up to be better and different until “somehow the emperor returned”.