Hello everybody!

I just received my new 20TB MG10 hard drives three days ago, and decided to run a badblocks test on them to check whether or not they were good. Well, here I am, with 2 disks (out of 6) currently reporting at least 1 bad block (I didn’t let the test continue on the entire drive, but it’s currently running a SMART extended test).

Considering I just purchased them, should I send them back? Or is it expected to see a few bad blocks on a 20TB drive? (Considering the capacity, it’s not like I’m very surprised to see one bad block).

But at the same time, I’m well aware of the fact that it’s not the number of bad blocks that’s a bad sign, but just the presence of them, so I want to be cautious.

So because I’ve read a bunch of conflicting information (some people say 1 is okay, some others is any bad block is --> RMA), I’m not sure what to do here.

Thanks guys!

  • binaryriot@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I never had a bad block on a brand new drive. At least not a reported/ detectable one. So if it’s truly a “bad block” (how exactly is it reported in your SMART data?) I would exchange the disks.

    • MysteryDash@alien.top
      OPBEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      Badblocks says 1 bad block found (0/0/1 errors), so it seems to be a corruption error.

  • silentdragon14@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    Badblocks are going to happen. But on a brand new drive it really shouldn’t. I would RMA while I can to start with a known good drive that will last the maximum number of years. There is also a fair chance they are trying to pass off a refurbished drive as new, and badblocks are one of the only hints if that were the case.