

They do matter. Because the fact that nobody took those critiques seriously is what caused people not to vote for her. The fact that nobody took those critiques seriously 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30, even 40 years ago - is how the United States entered the situation that it is now. Half a century of “barely good enough” on the “representatives” of the left and we wonder why America is the way it is.
And ultimately, she lost, because people didn’t vote. And those people clearly stated why. In advance. For years. Yet the Democrats still insisted that everyone do as they’re told.
Think about it, if the line had been drawn 40 years ago, and voters said “No, we won’t vote for someone who is merely not as bad as the other guy. We only will vote for someone we actually WANT to vote for”. Then maybe that election we would have got some shitty right winger due to low dem turnout. But the next election, the Democrats might have run someone who was actually more left leaning. But voters didn’t do that, and instead they get shitty half-left democrats, and this moves the window to the right. One day that window is far enough to the right to make room for Trump. That’s not only the responsibility of the Republicans dragging the window the right, that’s the responsibility of Democrats refusing to ever drag the window back to the left. And that’s a direct result of Democrat voters repeatedly sucking it up and voting for someone they don’t really like.
I truly believe that if Kamala had been elected, the same process would repeat, the window would move further right, and the next time a Republican won it would a Trump 3.0 type figure as a result. So as bad as it is that Trump is president, given that our option was lancing the infected boil now or letting it balloon some more and get even more infected, only to be lanced in a more disastrous way later. This was the decision in the minds of those who did not support Harris - even if you think they had the wrong idea, can you at least respect their reasoning and see how it is not the sort of petty revenge that you mistakenly imagine it to be?


















I hope you’re right, but from my perspective all the important and bad parts of the movement existed well before Trump. Trump assumed the position at the head of the movement after the fact. All this evil was festering in the country even back when Trump still called himself a Democrat and wasn’t involved in politics at all. His death will certainly be a blow and destabilize them for a bit, but the fact is that about 30% of the country is extremely xenophobic, extremely racist, extremely uneducated, very bigoted, very religious fundamentalist - And they do a lot better job of getting along with each other than everyone else. All you need to hang with that club is to say something like “fucking mexicans, right?” or even just wear your church hoodie. Trump is a good vessel to channel their energy, but they were doing a pretty good job actionably directing their energy themselves long ago. They have like 8 different options for figures to rally around next. The left has maybe Bernie, AoC, Mamdani, but can’t even agree on that. The left has no beloved podcasters, no beloved billionaires, no beloved news agencies. It’s an asymmetric battle because the right is intrinsically the establishment. Only real underdogs need rallying figures, but the right is only ever a faux underdog.