then that sounds like the primary issue

that’s not a real thing. communist organisations are rooted in their social and economic enviornment. to join such an org you will have to reach out to your local chapter and participate in local activities.

online what?

you should join a communist organisation

1. so something like NEP? It’s kind of strange to view it as an ideal system imho. If you recognise that private property relations are an issue, why do you still want to keep them
2. what exact problem are you trying to solve with a land tax that cannot be solved with just public ownership of land?
3. cool

like those that i pointed out in my other comments. for instance the way you describe property relations. you say that private property exists, but then you say that all corporations are collectivised and everything is regulated. where is private property then if its not in the economy and it is not respected by the state? then, you say that there are no landowners, but then say that all tenants become landowners and pay taxes for the land. then you seemingly walked back your “planned market economy is a true socialist economy” statement, now you just say market economy. so which one is it?

you didn’t just say that, you also said quite a few other things that are not coherent

a planned market economy is a true socialist economy

rereading this part makes me think this is a bit

private property exists alongside public and collective property

you say this

all corporations get split and collectivized by the workers

and then this

landowners get stripped of their landowner role, so the tenants get to be their own landowners, and they pay the taxes to the land and other stuff (taxation is NOT theft in any way, shape and form). property (whether private or public or collectivized) becomes regulated to avoid inequalities and such

then all of this

do you realise how incoherent this whole set of sentences is? do you have any practical experience you can point to where this all works?

i dont really care about high art or prime time tv shows. my point is not to compare it to other tv and say thats its better. my point is that its a tv show produced by disney and its not secretly super communist propaganda or something. businesses constantly use revolutionary aesthetics for profit.

i have. but like, its not that deep

its star wars

Same reason the USSR then and most post Soviet states today celebrate the New Year later into January by the Gregorian calendar than the actual Gregorian calendar New Year.

You probably mean Christmas. New years is celebrated on new year.

Yeah but we’re talking about pvda and they are in opposition, not in government.

??

Sorry but I don’t trust secondary trotskyist sources to represent pvda truthfully

Quite a few European countries do

The PTB-PVDA, worker party of belgium, renounced leninism

Since when?

Americans are so used to things just happening to them.

yeah even on the left people can’t really picture what permanent organising / a working class party looks like

The energy of all the people supporting Mamdani’s win must be channeled into a permanently mobilized mass movement, building independent, working class parties and organizations that will fight against the powers that be, to ensure these reforms become a reality, and to fight for even more.

been saying this. electing new deal politicians is not nearly enough