Umstrittener Text in der „Welt am Sonntag“: Wurde Elon Musks Pro-AfD-Artikel von einer KI geschrieben?
www.tagesspiegel.de
Mit einem kontroversen Gastbeitrag machte Elon Musk Wahlwerbung für die AfD. Tagesspiegel-Recherchen zeigen nun: Der Text stammt womöglich gar nicht von Musk selbst – sondern von einer KI.

Original reporting in German: https://archive.is/gWLZL

[W]hat if Elon Musk hadn’t written the article himself? What if Welt am Sonntag had not printed a controversial guest article by one of the most powerful people on the planet, but an AI-generated text created in seconds? One that presumably agrees with Musk’s views, but whose argumentation may have been cobbled together from millions of freely available bits and pieces about Germany and the AfD on the internet?

If one asks [Musk’s] language model Grok to write an opinion piece for a conservative newspaper that shows why only the AfD can save Germany, the program spits out a text that is remarkably similar to Musk’s “Welt” article. In tone, argumentation, structure - and in many places literally. Like Musk’s op-ed, the AI-generated text begins with the words: “Germany is at a critical point - its future is teetering on the brink of economic and cultural collapse”. This is followed shortly afterwards in both texts by the formulation that has particularly angered many in Germany: the AfD, it says, is the last spark of hope for Germany. Dozens more overlaps follow, some of them verbatim.

Translated with DeepL.com

  • Rykzon
    1·
    2 days ago

    Because it would show the massive failure of journalistic integrity by the Welt editors

    • ExtremeDullard@lemmy.sdf.org
      3·
      2 days ago

      But would it?

      Let’s say he used AI to write his turd. He used AI like he could have used a keyboard, or a dictation software, or dictated to a secretary (is that even a thing anymore?). The means of writing the piece is unimportant - although it certainly is interested to know that he used AI. The important bit is that he wrote the piece.

      At best, you could say Welt am Sonntag could have been more thorough and could have found out about the AI bit. But it’s a side information that’s not relevant to the main story, which is that Musk supports an extreme right German party.