heyhey,

this here might contain two questions actually.

  1. got an idea, what instrument might suit me?
  2. how, actually learn?

background

i am not new to learng stuff by myself, mostly languages in the widest sense. the only thing i can’t really get my head around is music. i know rudimentary how to read notes, but ofc don’t really grasp what they mean. when i learned a bit about electronics, that explained a lot more about music for me. i tried to learn the recorder (bc its was there) and keyboard (bc super versatile). by now, that all didn’t work. i am a beginner.

i guess that is abt how these are played. i am used to grab a book sit down in a comfy position and read. keyboards need setup and are relatively large. the recorder is small and portable, but you need a decent body position, to control your breath.

i was thinking about some kind of ukulele, maybe? how do i build a habit, that works for practice?

update

ty all! all your comments really helped a lot to think clearer abt the why qnd what. i am a little overwhelmed and can’t answer each of you. but tyvm! in some cases i feel like there is an answer that needs to get out. in others i don’t know what to say other than “ty for sharing!”

i grabbed a guitar from a friend, now my fingies hurt. but i am also surprised of how quick you can get interesting results from such an instrument. i will try it out a bit longer and then maybe try a ukulele. i know they are quite different, but more similar to each other tgan to flute or keys.

maybe there’s a journey starting. :)

  • kluczyczka (she/her)OP
    1·
    2 days ago

    yup i’ve read about the math behind this. thing is i do not know what any of that refers to in reality. it seems totally arbitrary to me. yet i am supposed to hear a 5th. (note that i studied the most abstract shit for years. abstraction is not my enemy.) my plan is to expose myself to this using any instrument, that’s easy enough to learn, until i understand.

    i tried guitar now for a few days. rn i doubt this is gonna work out. my ellbow and shoulder hurt and i still get no fingerposition that works (i.e. enough pressure, on only one string per finger).

    keys are maybe the better choice since you can at least see the relations, and i dont have to wrap my arm around a stick but i doubt, that i will sit in front of a keyboard regularly after 8 hours of work …

    idk i need to cry maybe.

    • village604@adultswim.fanEnglish
      2·
      15 hours ago

      It’s definitely arbitrary. A=440Hz is a relatively new standard (it’s actually an ISO standard). We didn’t even try to define pitch before like the 19th century, but it has ranged from 390-455.4Hz.

      See Concert Pitch on Wikipedia

      But with a guitar it’s pretty easy to use a tuner to mess with the pitch and hear why we settled on it.

      I can’t find the right term for it now, but there’s a phenomenon in music where slightly off key notes will smack into each other and have a subtractive effect while on key notes have an additive effect. You can see this in a large choir. Not everyone in the choir is going to be a phenomenal singer, but when you get dozens of people singing at once it can sound incredible.

      It might help to think of notes as kinda sorta being like wifi channels. They’re the frequencies that don’t interfere with each other.

      And yeah, the guitar definitely takes some getting used to. You’ll have to develop finger calluses and strengthen your fingers to be able to compress the strings properly. But learning any musical instrument requires some sort of physical stamina building.

      If you opted for an acoustic, I’d recommend buying the cheapest electric you can find. It doesn’t have to sound good, but it’s much easier to press the strings on one. You can also buy a practice guitar neck to work on it when having a full guitar would be a pain.

      Honestly, the piano is the best starter instrument. The keys are easy to learn, the keys are easy to press, and you get practice using your hands independently. The biggest drawback is that pianos are big and take up space. But, if you have a college around you, there’s a chance that there’s a piano lab that they’ll let you use.

      But there’s one instrument you have on you at all times that’s completely free: your voice. Like any other musical instrument, basically anyone can get good at it with enough practice. And you can practice while doing other stuff.

      I’m not really a classically trained vocalist, although I was in choir in highschool (it was the class you got stuck in if nothing else you needed was offered at that time), but I practice in the shower daily and have improved to the point where I’m close to being able to intentionally polyphonically sing (people have a second set of vocal chords, see throat singing).