We’ve had plenty of questions about what people miss from reddit that Lemmy had, or what they hope doesn’t come to Lemmy from reddit in future, but do you miss from the earlier days, before reddit that you would like to come back?
I think the only ‘problem’ I have is that the content is relatively scarce. I too need to put more effort into commenting and posting, like every one else should too.
That being said, I do like the idea of not using reddit anymore. I swear I am way more productive, even with the time spent on Lemmy. The community seems (at least generally speaking) more wholesome.
There are subreddits that I do miss, I am checking every week if they migrated, hoping they will make it!
I’m the same, the smaller community is nice, getting involved feels much less intimidating here. I think the majority of people that came here were the users from Reddit who welcomed positive discussion, which tells us what we can expect from Reddit in the coming months…
The crazy thing is that I find myself commenting way more in here. If I was to answer to an askreddit thread, it would just get lost, but since the community here is smaller, it feels like every comment has more relevance
Small forums where everybody knew everybody (there’s still some kicking around). Personal websites/blogs were fun. I think they could make a comeback now that it’s easier than ever to host and big social media is going to poo.
The era of personal websites was something else. I remember the weird and wonderful creations you could find on GeoCities.
Going outside
I miss the mostly text-based content that was replaced by low effort memes
Pre Reddit? I miss Digg and Diggnation podcast.
Post Reddit, I miss the size of the communities, but honestly, they quality of responses I’ve gotten here is much better. It’s also nice seeing all these new communities popping up. Soon you’ll be able to find a community for just about everything
Digg and Diggnation were so crucial to me seeing how the internet was really becoming something new (and I was obviously a TechTV fan before that). It lead to me learning about so many things about computers and OSes and made me give Linux another chance when Debian and Ubuntu were brought up on the vidcast (and attempting to use my laptop as a Hackintosh though it wasn’t able to go things like go online or do any 3D but was cool to try). So I guess other video/audio-casts were fun to see take off. The great Blu-ray keys protest that flooded the Digg site was also one of the first kind of big internet protest I was able to watch in real-time and participate. lol
I used the website stumbleupon.com. I used to waste hours on that site and just shuffle websites within my interests. It was a good way to find new websites to frequent.
Maybe the digg photoshop contests.
But really, I thought reddit was the perfect site when it came out. I’m very sad it has been taken over by a Musk clone.
r/PSBattles on Reddit is a thing. Or is it different than that?
I just never went looking for it on reddit.
Photoshop contests are always fun. I loved them on fark and somethingawful back in the day.
USENET. Actually useful USENET.
Yea, I was really sad when my then-current provider did not offer Usenet access.
Actually, being able to group or sort instances hierarchically like rec.books.whatever might be helpful in organizing all these discussions. Currently this feels like alt.everything. When lemmy grows further, this maght become even more confusing.
Is USENET still useful? I haven’t used it in over a decade and I hope it’s still around, but I would be kinda shocked if it’s still relevant.
I still have an account. It is still useful for grabbing binary content like TV shows and movies, but that takes a lot of setup.
What I really miss are the discussions. There, it’s not as useful as it once was. All the groups still exist, but many are overrun by spam. It would be nice to see a solution that makes USENET actually useful again.
Being part of a smaller community.
I had even stopped reading usernames. No subreddit has ever felt like a community to me. The only online places that did were my WoW guild, some other guild-based games, a brief period on Crunchyroll a long time ago, and more recently a Discord anime group which is all but inactive now.
The internet has changed in such a way. But so have I. Making friends online used to be super easy (talking 15-20 years ago). Nowadays, I can only do it in person.
I always miss many of the online friends I used to have and regret deeply how I didn’t put more effort into keeping them. I see a lot of people make the same mistake. I suppose friendship loss is something most of us need to go through to learn to value it.
IRC and eggdrops, or the equivalent. Okay so we spent half our time netsplit and pinging each other forlornly across gaps but you could do really worthwhile things with those basic tools, and most things were very portable across providers so you could straightforwardly move the whole kit and caboodle if a reason to do so arose, and you could self-host. I appreciate that this is probably more a commentary on slack/discord than forum culture, though.
pre-reddit? smaller niche communities where people actually knew each other. once social media got centralized on a few big platforms (namely reddit) most subs got so ridiculously popular that everyone was basically anonymous. it’d be nice to see actually communities form.
I miss (at least some aspects of) Slashdot’s moderation system, especially:
- the ability to provide reasons for the moderation (e.g. expressing the difference between +1, funny and +1, insightful), and
- metamoderation (voting on whether moderation actions were justified).
(It’s worth noting that other important aspects of Slashdot’s moderation system were that the range of comment scores was bounded to the range [-1, 5] and that users only had a limited number of modpoints that they were awarded occasionally based on karma, so the aspects I liked may or may not transfer well to different contexts like Reddit or Lemmy-style upvoting/downvoting.)
forum games and community events
I miss the old forums and discussion boards that we had pre “web 2.0”. I read a YA book series as a teenager that had a forum, and met one of the best friends of my life on it. I know people still do such things, but I’ve never really had a close knit community like we had back then, not since the likes of Reddit and other social media giants have dominated the way we all use the internet. I’d be very happy to go back to the internet of the early aughts and just stay there.
It was before my time, but from what I’ve heard I would have to agree. Some smaller subreddits and discord servers can emulate some elements of those communities, but it’s just not the same. Especially discord, it loves shoving nitro in your face, and finding old discussions is impossible unless messages happened to be pinned at the time.
