Somewhere during the Early Access Larian introduced the loaded / Karmic dice, to even out extreme effects of dice rolls. In EA this was enabled at default, and I assume the same will be true for the final release. It feels like it is a less pure D&D feature, since D&D gameplay is based on die rolls.
What do you think? Play with or without the Karmic Dice option enabled? And why?
On if you have no clue what you’re doing.
Off if you’re good at making OP characters and familiar with 5e.
It always makes rolls favor the one rolling, with a bigger bonus the more they’ve failed. So if you have a low attack bonus and miss frequently you’ll hit more often. But if you have a tank with 22 AC, they’ll also get hit (and crit) far more often with it on.
I’m fairly familiar with 3.5 and pathfinder 1 rules but never played 5e, how would it translate in terms of character building?
Severely overqualified. 5e is much simpler than 3.5 and PF1. If you’re familiar with those, you could probably even make fairly good builds in Kingmaker and Wrath of the Righteous (the PF1 video games) without any guides.
I haven’t touched BG3 Early Access specifically, but 5e has very little in common with 3.5e/PF1e.
It is actually a bit frustrating coming from those systems as i feel they are much better lol. The gsme is still fun though, i just wish it made informatiom about skills more detailed or accessible.
I play with it off, because I prefer to not have my rolls messed with in either direction. I don’t personally want to play with it giving me an artificial bonus and then likely dumping on me the next time I roll.
As someone else stated, if you don’t know what you’re doing keep it on for the sake of gameplay. Otherwise turn it off if you don’t want it
I assume it is possible to switch it on of off anytime during the campaign.
It’s an overall game setting, so yes. Thankfully you don’t have to worry about making the choice before starting
Personally I will be playing without Karmic Dice. I believe Larian’s concept behind it is like the DM that occasionally smudges the rolls during a game. The game is designed around you failing rolls just as much as succeeding so I will take what the dice wills.
That said people did testing during Early Access and found that on average you ended up hitting and getting hit more often in combat with Karmic Dice enabled as it sort of evens out your rolls. So if that interests you by all means go for it!
I hated the karmic dice. I found I failed skill checks noticeably more frequently with it on.
