I’m seeing across various instances that registration is going through manual approval as an anti-bot measure. As someone whose also run Fedi instances, I know how bad the bot problem is.
I do think invite links can get around this though. If we allow existing users to simply send a referral/invite to their friends (and have a tracker on who is inviting who), that’ll do a ton to both mitigate spam registration and allow people to join quickly.
The more obstacles we put in the way of registration, the more people will be dissuaded and go away. We’ve seen it with Mastodon (and now there’s this whole reputation of it being too complicated). We have a window here to fix stuff if we’re fast. People will eventually forget about the Reddit API and put up with it if we don’t offer a compelling alternative when the iron is hot.
I’m considering making a GitHub issue, if anyone has any thoughts or plans to work on it, let me know. I have a decent amount of connections on the Fedi and if enough people are serious about getting this ASAP, I can help out with the logistics/coordination.
I can say first hand I was confused on how to sign up. I tried joining lemmy.ml and wrote up an application which never got approved. After browsing for a few days I figured out I could sign up on any instance and found lemmy.ca, my people. lol. My application got approved very quickly there.
I doubt most people will be able to figure this out as it’s not intuitive and perhaps give up and move on to somewhere else. :(
Yea i tried to stick to the “main” lemmy instance. Still dusting out this federation stuff. But they are SWARMED with applicants, and after i learned beehaw was not a Midwestern beekeeping subreddit, i was able to get a home base.
Another problem is that you never actually receive a confirmation if your application was received and/or rejected, you are just sorta stuck in limbo after applying.
User created invites IMHO only make sense when there is a endorse chain that allows linking back who made the invite when there is abuse, but the simpler version that Akkoma/Pleroma has which allows site admins to create invite links that are valid for a certain number of new registrations would make sense as an option and is probably not too hard to implement.
Pleroma has such Invites, and Manyverse/SSB Rooms too.
This a great thing.
Very clever move, thanks
I think at the very least having this be an option would help a lot!
@Tomat0 I would also like to see invites, has anyone checked the roadmap or issue tracker to see if its already in progress there or that the devs are aware there is such a desire for such?
Devs stated it’s not a priority but if someone else were to do the work and make a PR, they would not be opposed to including it.
deleted by creator
Not invite-only, but invite as an option to bypass the usual manual approval process. Captchas from my experience aren’t effective, as PeerTube hCaptchas have been bypassed.
Seems like a good idea to me!
I think in a few days the peak of joiners will be over and an invitation feature might take longer to implement than that. Even if it were implemented in time, it would be hard to prevent the creators of those bots to just invite them. Yes, they can be identified as the people who let the bots in, but manually blocking those bots will be even more time consuming than manual checks at sign up, but correct me if I’m wrong.
