I assume there’s going to be the knee jerk reaction in this thread about not touching a classic.

No doubt the idea is classic, and combined with the writing and performances shaped American sitcom. But, I fail to see how a British version would take anything away from the original, even if it becomes more popular (very unlikely) in the same way the American version of The Office overshadowed (at least to Americans) the original British version. If anything, it would just spark a renewed interest in the original for a generation and demographic that never saw the original in broadcasts or syndication. The original is a distinctly American take on pub culture from a particular time. With a new cultural reference and a new millennium I have no doubt that there are new stories to be told. I don’t think an American reboot would hit the same though, too many expectations. A British version could be allowed to be different enough to be vital. The new show may suck, but it won’t be because the whole concept is a bad idea.

There’s potential there and we’ll give it a go if it happens. Why do Cheers UK and not just a new show? Makes it much easier to stand up to scrutiny and have a shot at being successful.

No it’s classic no matter where you live, just leave it alone.

There’s already Morse, Inspector Lewis, Endeavor, and Grantchester. Why do they need another show about a bunch of guys spending all of their time in a pub talking to each other?

Oi, Norman!

For anyone wanting a Scottish centric pub comedy I highly recommend Still Game.