This isnāt my effort post so it might be against the rules. Iām just linking and copying two posts from subreddits that have compiled all that has happened over the past week.
First, hereās a thread of all recent H3 controversies, sorted by date. There is a lot in there, so Iāll be copying the ones related to this topic.
October 15th
Ethan says 100% of the Jews he knows are struggling after Oct 7th and says Zionist is a slur
Ethan posts about defending āantisemitic terroristsā
October 16th
Ethan makes a video dedicated to canceling and de-platforming Hasan Piker, admits he wants to deplatform Hasan on Twitch for āinterviewing a terroristā, and shows an unlisted clip of Hasan titled āHamasAbiā
October 17th
Hasan says Ethan is too focused on his personal feelings and calls him self-centered
Ethan calls Hasanās stream āvile embarrassing trashā
October 19th
Ethan posts video titled, āTwitch has a major problemā
Frogan provides context for the āHabbibi passā tier list - A bunch of Arab streamers made a tier list on who had the Habbibi pass, the controversy was around the lowest tier which was titled ā Loves Sabraā i.e. likes Sabra hummus. Ethan claims this is antisemitic and a dog-whistle about Jewish people.
Ethan posts about Yahya Sinwar
October 20th
Frogan responds to Ethanās claims around hummus/āLoves Sabraā
Hasan debunks the Hummus/Sabra debate, says itās NOT antisemitism
October 21st
H3 Podcast covers Twitch, Frogan and antisemitism, says Twitch CEO Dan Clancy must resign and puts Nazi Symbols on Twitch CEO in his YouTube thumbnail
He successfully gets the Arab streamers banned off Twitch.
October 22nd
Ethan posts video titled 'I Wonāt Let Hasan Piker Lie About Me To His Audience, then lies about not knowing Destiny, says the Left is eating itself
Ethan claims he āconcededā on far-left ideals such as letting the Palestinians have a state
October 23rd
Hasan calls Ethan Islamophobic
Ethan makes an instagram story about nmplol
Hasan says Rashid is not a terrorist, just like Hila is not a terrorist
Hila admitted to raiding homes in Ramallah and move from her assigned desk job into combat roles because she was āboredā. BadEmpanada HAS MADE a video titled āHila Klein is a Terroristā due to her time in the IDF where she asked to be transferred to the Israeli-occupied West Bank, performed logistical duties for the IDF terrorist organization, and volunteered to tag along during an IDF terrorist attack against a Palestinian house in Ramallah.
Ethan targets Emma from Majority Report - LINK 1, LINK 2, LINK 3, LINK 4
Second, here is a thread correcting the misinformation Ethan spread about Hasan
My problem with Fidel Castro is that hes a well of lawyer, and while he technically isnāt exploiting anyone to get that money he doesnāt exactly do anything relating to his principals with it either. What, a failed electoral campaign is all he has to show for it? Heās not even a real socialist.
My problem with Mao Zedong is that hes the son of an affluent grain merchantā¦
Wait hold onā¦
My problem withā¦ Che is that hes a well paidā¦ Doctorā¦ Uuuhhh,ā¦
My problem with Leninā¦ Is hasā¦ A middle class lawyer
MY PROBLEM WITH ENGELS IS THAT HES A WEALTHY FACTORY OWNER
Fidel had two Rolex watches at the same time!?!
Listen. This is mostly a goof, but youāre literally making the same reactionary argument chuds make about all kinds of socialists.
The guy donates, he fundraises, he takes the stream to rallies and strikes, he talks to protesters, he uses union shops for his stupid merch, he houses his brother, father, and mother in his home, , paid for his brothers student loans, all his business ventures are organized as cooperatives, he doesnāt enforce IP law on fan channels clipping and shipping his content. Heās no Castro, but like I said, Castro had two Rolex watches š±.
I really donāt get where youāre going with this whole argument. All of those guys either worked working class jobs and/or literally became legendary revolutionary leaders. Even Engels wrote works that are still being analysed to this day. Hasan isnāt even on track to do any of that, let alone close to actually becoming it. Iād be glad to eat my own words and be wrong about him, with him in a 100 years being looked as some important figure of american socialism lol. You certainly canāt compare the kind of money todayās doctors or lawyers have in general vs. someone like Hasan, who just off his twitch contract has millions. Not to mention that his platform is a lot bigger than any of those guys had early on.
And in terms of two of Castro rolex watches, a guy in the same thread you linked points out that that watch was much cheaper back then, about 2k in todays money. Not little, but certainly not a whole lot either. Also, apparently these watches were some of the most accurate of their time, explaining why he has two and one of them is set to Moscow time. Not to mention he was literally a state official of a socialist country. Literally an excerpt from wikipedia
I mean, all his content is literally reacting to videos and news lmao. It would be pretty hypocritical if he did, since he doesnāt exactly abide by it most of the time anyway lol.
Itās funny, because Iām honestly not arguing that heās some kind of grifter. I like him, I just feel like he still has certain issues that donāt hurt to be pointed out. It just feels like heās not actually doing anything to differentiate him from any other progressive lib. I mean, fucking ludwig sold his company to his workers to become a coop, which doesnāt make him some revolutionary. Iād say someone like the guys from boy boy are doing much better in terms of covering various aspects of capitalism and bringing attention to exploitation some of us didnāt even was happening. Even fucking JT from Second Thought had homeland security knock on his door.
Iām just going to reiterate this. Iām not saying heās a revolutionary, but what I am saying is your critiques centered around his wealth and his engagement in consumerism echo fairly common anti-communist sentiments that have been levied against actual revolutionaries and revolutionary thinkers. It also treads close to the shores of type critique.
I view Hasan as the stoop before the door. He engages with JT, BoyBoy, The Deprogram, (and more) who do more to highlight, dissect, and explain both the horrors of capitalism, and the political theory to understand those horrors. Itās hard to say if I would have found my way to JT, BoyBoy, or The Deprogram if I hadnāt first landed on Hasanās stream several years ago. I could have just as easily landed on the streams of Destiny or Vaush and become more reactionary instead of less reactionary. Hasanās position within the Internetās leftist activation pipeline lays in the front, and I think because of that, itās almost required that he sits closer to a āprogressive libā than an out and about Marxist-Leninist like JT Chapman. Youāre not going to onboard disillusioned progressives onto the leftist train by jumping straight into the deep end of leftist political theory. You have to disarm their anti-communist world view first, which is something I think Hasan is fully capable of doing, and has done for plenty of people.
This is something Iām sure you already know, so Iām moreso laying it out for others who might read this comment. You need an onramp for people, and I think Hasan performs that role. Iām not concerned with how big his house is, how fancy his car is, how expensive his stupid Hawaiian shirts are, so long as he continues to disarm peopleās anti-communist world view.
A Reddit link was detected in your comment. Here are links to the same location on alternative frontends that protect your privacy.