I’m currently using T480. Thinking of upgrading to a second hand new-ish model.

Initially I was interested in ThinkPad L14 gen 2 or gen 3, but I’ve read that the wifi card is not upgradeable. I also read that newer models block installing SSD into the WWAN slot. I prefer having separate SSD for installing secondary OS.

Any recommendations of newer models with dual SODIMM slots, upgradeable wifi card, ability to add SSD to WWAN slot?

Thank you.

  • makingStuffForFun@lemmy.ml
    3·
    1 year ago

    This is a GREAT question. I have a gen 6 x1 carbon. But, everything is soldered on. So I can’t upgrade. When she eventually dies, I’d rather a machine I can upgrade. As long as it’s new enough. Keen to hear the answer.

    • jaenneken
      1·
      1 year ago

      the gen 6 is not the worst. Wifi is upgradeable as well as wwan is. The Display can be upgraded if yours is not one of the favourable ones or better ones appear in the market. As long as you have the 16gb version it has plenty of years to go.

    • narwhal@lemmy.mlOP
      1·
      1 year ago

      My t480 is still running fine actually. It’s an amazing device.

      I added secondary SSD to wwan slot to install Manjaro Cinnamon on it.

      Memory is now 32GB.

      Upgtaded wifi card to AX201, if I remember correctly.

      I really want to have the option to do the same with a newer laptop if possible.

    • narwhal@lemmy.mlOP
      1·
      1 year ago

      I haven’t really looked at P series because they’re too big for me. But I’ll take a look. Thank you for the recommendations.

  • Snuupy@lemmy.ml
    1·
    1 year ago

    I’ve given up on new thinkpads. Here are my list of grievances from Lenovo:

    • faulty BIOS updates: I had to pay $130 to extend my warranty as Lenovo released a faulty BIOS update that bricked my P52. Bad QA.
    • poor engineering design for planned obsolescence: loose usbc ports that are soldered onto the main board so you can’t replace them easily (and you have to replace the entire motherboard)
    • poor thermals: they literally design 13/14" laptops to have poor thermals to push you towards the x1e/z16/etc. lines. For example, on the T14 AMD gen1, they hard limited the CPU temps to never go above 85C via BIOS. You cannot change this with ryzenadj. It will force TDPs to stay at 11W once it hits 85C (although if you stay at 84C, you can sustain 25W TDP)
    • soldered everything (or poor build quality): they want to upcharge you out of the ass to get more RAM. Ever since after the T480, they have soldered at least one slot.
    • artificially making speakers worse on the cheaper (T/L/E) lines to entice you to buy X1/Z lines. Apple has figured this out for years.

    At this point, Lenovo/ThinkPad is anti-consumer/consumer hostile. The thermals and poor software development practices are an engineering culture issue. The rip-off pricing for soldered RAM upgrades ($400 for 32GB, lol) are a ripoff. They also solder the wifi card for planned obsolescence now.

    I refuse to buy any laptop that I cannot swap/upgrade both RAM slots, and cannot change the wifi card. Is it my device or Lenovo’s?

    I refuse to buy another thinkpad at this point. Granted, other brands (HP/Dell/Apple) are worse, but that doesn’t mean this behavior is acceptable.

    Personally, I’m waiting for a framework 16. I’ve also looked at some of those Tong Fang/Mechrevo (non soldered)/Firebat laptops but I don’t know how they are long term and there is no supply chain for long term replacement parts like there is for framework.

    • narwhal@lemmy.mlOP
      1·
      1 year ago

      Yeah. L14 is more upgradable now in terms of memory. That’s what made me interested in L series over T series when I looked around.

  • jaenneken
    1·
    1 year ago

    Afaik the Amd versions always have classic wifi cards in their m2 slots that can be replaced with whatever you like. They also tend to have 32gb ram options available (while the intel only offer 16 - eg x13) which helps to make them future proof. If Wwan slots can be used for ssd I don’t know. My current daily driver is a x280 with a 13inch panel and an ax201.

    • fuckwit_mcbumcrumble@lemmy.world
      1·
      1 year ago

      I can confirm that my T14s AMD Gen 2 does have a replaceable wifi card, but all RAM is soldered since it uses LPDDR_ and sadly LPDDR5 and up will be soldered only. So you have to choose between slow replaceable RAM or fast soldered RAM.