Kind of amazing how many instances are blocking lemmygrad as soon as they’re created. I know that liberals really don’t like dissenting opinions but goddamn

  • ImOnADiet [he/him]@lemmygrad.mlOP
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    2 years ago

    It just seems like that isn’t a great argument to convince people to trust the DPRK to me. Like if they already don’t like the state, they’re not going to trust anything that comes from the government. I guess my point is that lifting the sanctions (and stop propping up the Republic of Korea’s government) is the bare minimum that any socialist should agree to. I only used north Korean because I wanted it to be clear that I was talking about someone from the DPRK

    • CriticalResist8@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      2 years ago

      The only way we can “undo” the miseducation most of us have received on the DPRK is through proper reeducation. I know reeducation often has bad connotations, but I’ve never seen the word that way personally, reeducation is good!

      They need to realise as the first step that all this cartoon evil stuff they’ve been told about the DPRK makes no sense, and for that they have to see that the DPRK is a normal country like all others, with a functioning state and government. We shouldn’t disguise the truth because liberals are not ready to hear it – we need to be confident in it, and they will come around eventually.

      It’s hard to deny, for example, what Pyongyang looks like and that they’re building free housing for their population: https://twitter.com/NatalieRevolts/status/1513708649386020869. And sure, they’ll find counter arguments in the early stages, but eventually they’ll have to confront reality and realise the “only the high officials of the regime live in Pyongyang” makes no sense and does not hold up to scrutiny.

      But I’m not pulling you into a debate or struggle session here 😀 I think for the most part we agree.

    • redtea@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      2 years ago

      I am in broad, near total, agreement with you. There’s just the point about trust that I want to address.

      For me, it’s not necessarily about ‘trusting’ the DPRK. It starts with recognising that we can’t trust anything Western governments or media say about the DPRK.

      We know for certain that we cannot trust Western voices. (1) They have been caught in too many lies already. (2) Whether they lie or not, the world looks different from a dialectical materialist perspective, which makes bourgeois conclusions faulty even if they’re honest.

      If this is correct, it means rebuilding a model of everything that capitalists have ever spoken about. That includes the DPRK, Cuba, etc.

      In that case, we need to look for data and evidence from somewhere else, which happens to include official e.g. DPRK sources (although we can critically analyse Western sources and find the kernel of truth if there is one, to help us do the same to those un/official pro-DPRK sources and come to a new conclusion).

      As for that conclusion, we do know some uncontrovertable facts. The US and it’s allies invaded Korea, killing millions of people. They invaded as a neocolonial project and to prevent the spread of communism. The US never left. An invading army that doesn’t leave is almost by definition an occupying force. That means the south of the peninsula is occupied by a foreign enemy.

      Under these conditions, we cannot expect enlightenment in the region. As it happens, I’m convinced the north is a lot closer to paradise than Western media and officials ever suggest (not to say that it is or ever could be a paradise—I’m not a utopian socialist). For the majority of people, it may even be better in the north than in the south. But other ‘leftists’ don’t have to agree about that.

      I think that recognising these details is necessary to convince westerners in general to act in solidarity with Korea to achieve the goals that you rightly say we need to achieve. We’re not going to get anywhere with lifting sanctions for so long as westerners implicitly agree that some level of occupation/action is necessary because the DPRK is XYZ.

      After recognising these details, it becomes clearer that western leftists need to stop caring so much about what goes on in other countries (unless it’s to offer critical support) and focus instead on preventing their governments from conducting/facilitating the most violent empire in history. (Which I think you’re already saying?)

      • ImOnADiet [he/him]@lemmygrad.mlOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        2 years ago

        was reading through another thread and this massive post (no hate!) popped up in the top right corner of my screen and scared me lol. I think this aligns with my thoughts on the matter pretty closely!

        their governments from conducting/facilitating the most violent empire in history. (Which I think you’re already saying?

        Yes, I think this is foremost our job as socialists in the imperial core