• CyberEgg
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    5 months ago

    You bring no arguments I could ignore. You only make assumptions and claims.

    How do you even come to the conclusion BSW was authoritarian (that describes the use of (or desire to reach) a strong central power the rejection of political plurality) or left wing (which is defined by striving for societal progress and especially equal rights and equal chances for everyone, which BSW denies migrants).

    and mostly a east Germany phenomenon.

    That is something you never brought up before. What point do you think you make with this phenomenon?

    they will probably sit left from the view of the podium.

    Where you sit usually concurs with your political positions, but does not define it.

    If we’d take the Horseshoe theory again

    Why should we, since it’s debunked?

    Another takeaway is that they are absolutely a threat to democracy,

    Again something you claimed but never supported with anything.

      • federal reverse@feddit.orgM
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        5 months ago

        You are just digging a bigger hole with every comment, adding more inconsequential arguments.

        Your original claim was that they are an SED clone. Which is just not true. That would also not make sense, given that we live in a vastly different time than the original Cold War era.

        BSW is a party that, for the moment, has way more presence in political talk shows than it does substance. They have a prominent ex-Linke face, they have ex-Linke members, but they also have nationalist and socially regressive views. Calling them left-wing is thus not particularly appropriate either.

        And just like CyberEgg, I absolutely don’t understand why you bring in all the arguments that don’t do anything for your case. E.g: Yes, BSW is popular in Eastern Germany. But that doesn’t mean they’re an SED clone or left-wing. It just means that a bunch of people in Eastern Germany voted for this weird cult.

        And for the record, none of that means that either CyberEgg or I like BSW.