Account was from 2011 with almost 5000 comments.
I am still unsure how to proceed now. At least gonna edit my comments before deleting my profile.
Still think it would be fun if one of the powerdelete suits could just bloat up every comment to max length with nonsense using GPT
shreddit does this - both the $15 shreddit.com and the free scripts available from github
shreddit does use the API tho, something to keep in mind.
FYI we are tracking GDPR request timelines: https://kbin.social/m/RedditMigration/t/50981/Reddit-Data-Retrieval-Request-timeline-thread
But the API won’t be open to us forever, right? I thought that it would close today.
The api is still open, but you can’t exceed 100 per minute per “Reddit app” unless you pay. So if you want to delete your entire post/comment history, you’ll need to Register a new app and it will take some time to delete everything. At least that’s how I understand it.
The thing that worries about this is that tools like github shreddit may not be designed to rate-limit themselves to no more than 100 api calls per minute yet so someone who uses this tool today or after while trying to leave reddit mistakenly ends up owning reddit quite a bit of money. shreddit.com is safer i think as you aren’t using your own api key - so the company behind the website is on the hook if they fail to make the adjustment. That’s why it was so important to get your archive before the API changes, that way you could erase or overwrite with peace of mind. Alas the builtin 30 days and the timing of the announcement meant that in theory almost no one would get it in time. Since June has 30 days, someone who requested immediately after the pricing announcement on May 31 would just get it the day before at latest (just yesterday).
100 per minute is faster than the speed at which I deleted my history. So I guess we can still help people deleting their history.
I used the archive which is shared around and extracted my posts to get the id of my comments and deleted those, like 30 per minute. But I guess that if we rebuild a database with the author as a key then we can pretty quickly return a list of id’s based on an author. Then the user can feed this list to a python script by himself and delete himself.
What I couldn’t do in time is edit the posts as I ran in some weird index errors that I couldn’t bypass.
I edited and deleted all my posts and comments, yet a google search will show all my comments and posts still there. If I edit and delete the posts from the post page it works, but I did it through my profile and it only hid my comments and didn’t even apply the edits…. Kinda frustrated and have no resolution with Reddit. Waiting to see if my comments are still there in my gpdr request.
This is not how it works. Google has its own copy, possibly a stale one. Nothing Reddit can do about it. As much as I’d love to blame it on Reddit (or Google for that matter), this is just a search engine working as intended.
No, this is not google cache. This is the same article on Reddit.com.
I accidentally wandered into a Reddit thread via Googling something (it’s everywhere) and noticed I had gotten mine as well in a message. Looking through it I don’t know how useful it really is to have other than for posterity, but the sad part was in thinking that it was just my comments with no context, and those discussion chains are all but lost. Some probably have missing parts due to deletions, and of course they all would require going to Reddit to even read, unless I can just use the URL to maybe find it in an outside archive?
I know it’s more than just Huffman behind all this, but I keep thinking of the quote that one person can make a difference. That difference isn’t always a good one, and burning things down is always easier than building.
There are datahoarders out there who have complete copies (at least as complete as physically possible) of every post and comment ever put on Reddit, I’ve seen torrents of them. They’re multiple terabytes, though, so I didn’t keep a copy of the link - I’d never download something that big.
They will be preserved, and perhaps someday live again on some piratical website or in the memory of some shady AI.
same boat here. Inquired when it did not come in a few days and they said it can take up to 30. I too have had my account for awhile so im glad you posted as maybe that is just the hold up.
I went all out and deleted my account out right. didn’t care if my comments or what not cameback they where just to reddit. I hit the frontpage 5x in 6 years but that was crossposted content I found on reddit sorting by rising :P Anyway at least you got everything!
I’m considering to delete my account under GPDR, that would mean they’d have to also delete my conent right?
I don’t believe so. They’d have to remove identifying information, but my imperfect understanding is outside of that they are allowed to keep the content.
Some of the posts or comments could include personal information. Wouldn’t Reddit be putting itself at risk of a lawsuit by leaving comments intact while executing a GDPR deletion request?
I don’t know…
Posts submitted by other users could also contain your personal identifying information, do they have to delete that somehow too? If not, what’s the difference? If so, how does any social media site comply with this law?
Maybe there’s some carve out where your own posts count and other people’s don’t, but it’s not obvious that that has to be the case…
Like I said, I have an imperfect understanding of the law.
Yeah, that‘s true. I guess it would be a grey area that would have to be judged on a case by case basis.
In case of an Instagram profile it would be quite intuitive that the pictures (especially ones containing the users face and other personal information) would fall under personal information. So Facebook could not get away with just anonymising the posts. In the case of reddit that would be more difficult of course…
